He who has a why to live can bear almost any how.
Nietzche
So I was trying to think up some ways to get more eyeballs on my blog and I thought, “I’ve got it, why not tell everyone the meaning of life! I mean, it’s kind of an important question right? I think a lot of people might like to know the answer, so I’m gonna give it to you. Yeah, that’s right. I’m going to tell you the meaning of life. You’re welcome. We’re gonna get to it in a second but first, a little spoiler warning, you ready? I know this will come as a shock to some of you, but I must confess, I don’t know what the meaning of life is. At least not exactly. Now before you get upset with me, let me say that I wasn’t completely lying to you. What I do know is a meaning of life. See, I can’t tell you what the meaning of your life is. Only you can do that and you absolutely should. What I can tell you is what my meaning of life is and hopefully, it will provide you with some inspiration.
Some of you may be familiar with a psychiatrist named Victor Frankl. He became famous for writing about his experiences in concentration camps during WW2. He endured some of the most difficult experiences a human being could ever face and yet, instead of breaking him, those experiences strengthened his will to live. A popular quote of his that sums up his basic philosophy is as follows, “Life is never made unbearable by circumstances, but only by lack of meaning or purpose.” In other words, life can be very difficult at times and so we must find a why, a reason to go on living, a reason to work hard, a reason to bear the sadness, pain, and all the rest. In the concentration camps, Frankl noticed that this meaning in life, or lack thereof, was the single most important factor in determining how the various other prisoners handled their situation. He noted that some people who had gone into camp young and in top health would wither down to nothingness, while other older and far less healthy prisoners seemed to react fairly well to their predicament. It didn’t matter the gender, the age, the education, or former economic status of the prisoner, in this new environment where all were in a sense equal, what mattered was each individual’s reason for living. If the prisoner believed they had something worth living for, something that gave their life meaning, they would do as well as anyone could expect under such devastating circumstances, while those who didn’t have that meaning wasted away or committed suicide. It should also be mentioned that often these prisoners either didn’t know the fate of their loved ones or they had been murdered. So having a loved one as a reason to go on living often wouldn’t do. The reason had to be intrinsic to the person. At the end of the war, Frankl used these insights to form the basis of Logotherapy, his own form of psychotherapy based on the belief that the primary motivational factor in humans is in finding meaning in their lives.
While I hope that you never experience anything remotely close to the cruel experience of being a prisoner in a concentration camp, I do believe there’s value in at least imagining yourself in some kind of similar experience. Take away your family and friends, take away your wealth, your degrees, your possessions, take away the things you do for entertainment, take away your youth or good health, take away mirrors to see your physical appearance, take away the opinions of others, take away everything and see yourself naked both literally and figuratively. So now then, what is left? Whatever it is, it is you in your most pure. When it comes right down to it, this is exactly what I’m trying to accomplish in my life and with this blog. I want us to see ourselves in our purest form and ask ourselves, “who is this person?” Well, this person is the complex psychology of everything that ever happened to them and their perception of those things. Yes, but we’re taking away all of that for a moment. So, what does this person consist of? That’s an easy one right? They consist of organs and blood and on a deeper level, they consist of atoms and molecules, the very same ones found in all other humans, other animals, the planet, the stars, the cosmos. In a very real sense, you are not you, you belong to the universe. So then, what is true to say is that the only thing that makes you you is, whatever it is you decide to be. We assign meaning to ourselves, to our lives. My grandfather used to tell me, “Hey tiger, remember, what you put up here,” he would take his finger and tap the side of his forehead, “What you put up here, no one can ever take away.” Simple advice? Yes, absolutely. And absolutely true and profound. The identity that you develop for yourself is the basis for everything else. So it is of the most extreme importance that you think on this. You see, you are not what happened to you, you are not what others believe you to be, you’re not even who you believe yourself to be. What you are is whatever you decide you want to be. Now I could tell you what you should be. I could recommend for instance that you start by choosing to be good. I think that’s solid advice, but the problem is of course that I’m suggesting that to you. You haven’t committed to being good for any other reason than because some guy who has a blog told you to do it. You have no real dog in the fight. You have to decide on a course of action that has meaning behind it. Meaning that puts your life into context, meaning that is innate to who you are at your core. That’s the only kind of meaning that has real power. The power to motivate you through the good times and the bad. If there was a terrible car accident and out of everyone close to you, you were the only one to survive, would your meaning still hold up? When you can answer yes to that kind of question, you know you’re really onto something.
If you think on this and you either don’t come up with a meaning that feels satisfactory or you think of a meaning but worry it might change in time, that’s fine. I’d recommend coming up with the best thing you can think of, but you must understand that this meaning you assign to life is evolving just like life itself. As your experiences change, so to will your meaning. This is why it’s best not to think in terms of absolutes and specifics. A broader approach with room to evolve is best. Let’s say for example that you decide the meaning of your life is to help others. Well, if you’re a parent this could mean focusing on giving your child the best possible childhood experience. When the child is grown, this may evolve into helping others in your community. The basic meaning hasn’t changed, only its strictest definition.
The answer lies in evolution…
I do not consider myself to be an overly spiritual person. I don’t burn sage in my home to purify it and I don’t own any healing crystals, but I do believe in invisible and unknown forces in the universe. I believe in them because I’ve seen them at work time and time again in my life. You can call it God or evolution or whatever you like, but I am convinced of its existence. So what am I talking about? I’m talking about how the nature of the universe is in expansion, forward momentum. I’m talking about how everything is constantly evolving. About how everything in the universe seems to be learning. Physical evolution in itself isn’t a mystery, after all, our old pal Darwin figured that one out well over a hundred years ago, but I’m saying that’s not where it ends. I believe evolution is everywhere. It is not limited to the physical. It’s in each of us mentally and spiritually. This is exactly why the answer to man’s motivation is in finding meaning for his life. It’s what we are here on this earth to do, to gain knowledge and to use that knowledge in some way to further our understanding and continued evolution. Consider this, why do we have babies, raise them, and then we die? Why does the cycle repeat over and over again? Why not just have a couple of billion people on the planet that just live forever? Because that’s a stagnant system. The ability for one person to learn and grow and innovate is limited. After a certain age, most people have already had all of their really good ideas and so it’s time for them to go and for the next generation to come in and improve on the ideas of the last generation. If you think about it in your own family, perhaps you can see it more clearly. Think of the beliefs and parenting skills of your grandparents and then of your parents and then of you, can you notice any evolution? I believe I can, and that’s not to say that my grandparents and parents weren’t smart and capable people, but I had the opportunity to watch them and see where they went right and wrong. I then took that knowledge and applied it to my parenting skills for my daughter. Now surely it’s not a perfect system. I will lose some good qualities that my parents had and pick up some bad ones that they didn’t have, but if on the whole, I’m doing an even slightly better job at parenting, then the general principle remains true. There is forward progress being made. We see this in our society as well. Certainly, technology is evolving, but society itself is evolving too. We are becoming more liberal, more accepting of others, less violent, and so on. It may not always appear this way because there will always be setbacks and the rate of positive change is never as fast as we might like, but it is there and statistics will back me up on this. Put simply, the universe wants us to grow. So let’s see what that looks like in a single person’s life.
Something happened to you. Genetics play a big part too, but something happened that hurt you and gave you a scar. This happened when you were very young and it informed your life. It played a significant role in making you the person that you are now. It happened and maybe there was some attempt by a parent to help you deal with it and maybe there wasn’t. Either way, you found yourself in uncharted waters. You, as the person you are, had to deal with something that was beyond your ability and it was extremely difficult. Somehow, over the years, you did learn to deal with it simply because you had no other choice. If you were lucky, then the scar wasn’t too deep and you found a healthy way to deal with it. But more than likely you struggled with it and you did some things right in dealing with it and some things wrong and that scar has followed you throughout your life, all the way to this very moment. So what does this scar have to do with the meaning of life? It has everything to do with it because your scar, the one that might look similar to other scars on other people, but is not quite the same, that one that is uniquely yours, that scar is also your story. You can choose to ignore it. The vast majority of people do exactly that. They cover it up with legal or illegal drugs or some other addiction or they become hyper-focused on work or they have their 2.5 perfect kids, a beautiful house, and a two-week vacation to Disney World every year, and these people, they’ll look at you like you must be outta your fucking mind like, “Scar? What scar? I had a perfect life, I am having a perfect life! Can’t you see how perfect my life is?” And these people are lying. They may be lying to themselves so badly that they don’t even know they’re lying, but they are. So the meaning of life then is to not lie. To not distract yourself with whatever bad habit you choose, but to take a trip back in time to a scary place. To the place where you got that scar. You need to become your own parent. You need to go back to that place and handle the situation the way it should have been handled long ago. You need to become the parent for yourself that your real parent or guardian never was. Of course, you can’t literally go back to that place, but you can do it in other ways. What people don’t understand is that time travel exists. It has always existed, just not in the way they show it in movies.
You can time travel through your memories. You can time travel by having those difficult conversations with the people from your past. The kind of conversations where you say things like, “You should have been there for me! It really affected me when…” or “I forgive you” or “I don’t forgive you”. You can time travel through therapy. You time travel back to a place in your mind where you allow that event to become so painfully real and present that you either break down in tears of sadness or tears of rage or both. You time travel again and again until it doesn’t hurt so bad anymore. Until you feel comfortable with your scar because you feel comfortable with yourself, you feel comfortable in your own skin. The only way out is through. You must go through the pain of your past before you can come out the other side. This is a seriously challenging journey in and of itself and is beyond the scope of this article to get into any detail.
Roads? Where we’re going we don’t need road.
Doc Brown (Back to the Future)
Okay. So let’s say you found yourself a good support system and you carefully went through the pain in your past, so now what? Can you just go live happily ever after? Not exactly. You can’t just go on with your life because you realize that whatever your scar is, that’s you. Like it or not, you are defined not by your scar exactly but by your response to your scar. This doesn’t mean that you must live the rest of your life with heavy trauma, quite the opposite. What you realize in this journey is that you’re stronger than your scar, you’re stronger than the people that hurt you and so you are now in a place of real knowledge and true power. And here’s where the whole meaning of life comes in. You’ve gone back in time and saved yourself figuratively and now your job, the meaning of your life is to take all that knowledge you’ve gained on your journey and use it to save other people literally and in doing this you contribute to the larger goal of the universe, evolution.
Sounds simple right? Well, it is. But it’s also the hardest thing you’ll ever do. Just look around you at all the people who haven’t even begun to do it. And do you want to know why? Because it’s the absolute scariest shit anyone can face. The very fact that you’re reading this, assuming you’re not my mom (hi mom), should tell you that you’re already ahead of most people. You see through all the bullshit and you want something deeper. You’re so much braver than you give yourself credit for. Real bravery is admitting all your issues, all your fears, all your hang-ups and being able to look at them honestly, being vulnerable enough to admit them to another person, and then finding the strength inside yourself to heal them.
Now I’ve been talking about childhood scars this whole time and it’s because usually, that’s where the most significant scar is formed, but it doesn’t necessarily have to be limited to childhood trauma. People will experience different traumas and different scars throughout their lives and so their path to meaning may start later in life or change or evolve with time. You have probably heard of someone who lost a child or another important person in their life. Maybe it was due to cancer. This person used to have a normal job but after getting this new scar they change course. They form and head a charity dedicated to cancer research. This is exactly what they’re supposed to do. This is evolution at work and it’s heartbreaking but also beautiful. People often ask things like “Why would God take such a good person?” Now don’t get me wrong, I’m not claiming to know God’s plan, but the best and most obvious answer to that question is this exactly. So that one person that was close to the person that died might be filled with enough passion and motivation to seek answers to the problem in hopes that future people won’t have to suffer the same fate. In its most basic form, this is the meaning of life. Learning from the mistakes of the past to make the future better.
The cool thing about this meaning is that if you look out for it, you will begin to see how the universe or God, or whatever you want to call it, is pushing you in this direction. It wants you to understand yourself and your scars. It wants you to heal and it wants you to use what you’ve learned to help others. You may be already doing it. What is your job, hobby, or area of interest? Can you relate it in some way to old scars? What are the things in your life that are currently causing you pain or frustration? Is it possible that these current events could somehow be traced back to a very old and unresolved wound? And if so, what do you think it is the universe is trying to tell you? It’s important to notice these signs and to try to interpret them correctly because if not, they will continue to happen. Think of the universe as a really annoying and persistent charades partner. They can’t just come out and tell you the meaning of your life, so they will just keep trying to tell you it in some different way. It’s your job to listen and interpret properly. My guess is that you already know exactly what the universe is trying to tell you, the real question is whether or not you’re finally ready to listen.
So there you go, the meaning of life, or at least a version of the meaning of life. I hope you found something of value in it. I’d like to end by returning once more to family. I’d like to show you just how powerful this meaning can be. Let’s say you do nothing else of significance in your life other than being a good parent. I have this little thought experiment I think about whenever I’m finding parenting particularly difficult, it’s about the awesome potential of one person. You could have a family line filled with generations of sadness, abuse, and dysfunction. A family line seemingly destined to continue this curse for generations to come. It’s quite simple really, a child is raised in a dysfunctional home and eventually grows up to be a dysfunctional parent, has children of their own and the process repeats itself. But, if one person breaks that cycle. If one person says, “Screw that! I may not know how to do it, but I’m going to work at this thing and I’m going to be a good parent and raise my child the way I wished I had been raised.” And that person, maybe they’re not perfect but they show up and they do the work and they raise a good kid and that kid, he or she will never know any of the generations of trauma that came before them and they will grow up to be good parents and so on and so forth. And though that first person who decided to break the cycle is long gone and will never see what he created, the results will still be there for generations to come. And all those new family members will be better human beings and they’ll be more kind and loving to everyone they come in contact within their lives and eventually, that positive ripple effect from one person deciding to step up and do the right thing will be so vast that it would be impossible to quantify. That is what’s at stake. That is why it’s so important. That is what the universe wants from you. That is the meaning of life and if you do it, the universe will smile on you for the rest of your days.
I wanted to give a special shout-out to Ryan Kraus, host of the “Cold Case Murder Mysteries” podcast. So what does true crime have to do with the meaning of life? Well, I gotta tell you guys, this ain’t your mom’s true-crime podcast! In my opinion, Ryan is the best kind of genius, balancing on the edge between crazy and profound. He dissects some popular murder/mysteries on his podcast through the lens of his unique brand of evolutionary psychology. I can’t say I always agree with him but when I do, it’s like getting a peek behind the curtain of the universe. Anyway, I seriously doubt I could have written this piece without his valuable insights into the nature of the human mind and beyond. So thank you, Ryan! I’d highly encourage you to give him a listen. A recent podcast of his on the murder of Amy Mihaljevic is as good a place as any to start, particularly if you’re interested in some of the ideas I presented here.